HomeBuying GuidesAppliancesHow To Buy The Best toaster

How To Buy The Best toaster

Looking to buy the best toaster? Check out our guide below and you’ll be well-placed to select the correct one for your needs.

You can’t imagine a kitchen without a toaster, can you?
For most of us, toasters are a kitchen necessity, and with so many various models on the market, knowing how to pick the best toaster from the duds is critical.

On this page, you’ll find all of the toasters that have reached our high standards for toasting, from the best budget toasters to those that combine design and functionality.
For under £30, you can get any ordinary two-slice or four-slice model, but the best toasters will put you back a little more.

If you’re not sure which characteristics you need or should be looking for, our shopping guide below will walk you through the process of selecting the best toaster.
We’ve got the lowdown on all the top toasters in their respective categories, whether your budget is £40 or £400.

How do you pick the right toaster for you?

Purchasing a new toaster should be straightforward: choose one you like and can afford, order it from Amazon, and wait for it to come the next day.
While that may be true, there are a number of useful features on today’s toasters that are worth noting.

Is it better to choose a two-slice or four-slice toaster?

This is the most important decision you’ll have to make.
We recommend a four-slice toaster unless you have limited worktop space or live alone.
It makes busy breakfast times, or just trying to get two people to eat beans on toast, a lot easier.
As a result, we normally only recommend (and review) four-slice machines, but keep in mind that there are usually two-slice variants of them that function quite identically to their larger brothers.

A two-slice toaster will feature only one browning control (timer), but a four-slice device may have one or two such controls.
A single control implies the timer is set for all four slots, which is acceptable if everyone wants their toast to be made in the same way.
With two timers, you can set each pair of slots independently, allowing you to toast crumpets on one side while toasting on the other, or have “his and hers” slots adjusted to your tastes.

What should I be looking for in a toaster?

The reheat button normally starts a one-minute cycle to warm up cold toast.
This function is marked on the timer dial rather than being a distinct button on some toasters.
Similarly, the “a little longer” button adds 30 seconds to your toast.

You can use the keep-warm function to keep the fire going until you’re ready to drink your coffee and orange juice.
If you’re short on time, though, a quick toasting function is ideal.
A warming rack allows you to heat foods like rolls and croissants over the toaster’s heat.

For frozen bread, a thaw setting is useful.
It defrosts the bread before switching to the toasting cycle.
Each model is different: some require pressing the defrost button before lowering the bread carriage, while others require pressing the defrost button after turning on the toaster.

You can take a peek at the browning process by pausing – sometimes known as “lift and look” – before pressing the toast back down to where it left off.

By pushing the slots up, high lift prevents you from burning your fingers and allows you to securely retrieve your toast.

A bagel setting is in handy when you only want to toast one side of something, such as bagels or English muffins.

If you enjoy toasted sandwiches, a sandwich rack can be a lifesaver.

If you like ultra-thin or doorsteps, or even bagels or muffins, variable-width slots accommodate a wide range of thicknesses.

Is a crumb tray a must-have accessory?

All of the toasters we’ve seen have crumb trays built in, which gather crumbs in the toaster’s bottom and can be easily slid out for disposal.
Around the back, most have twin crumb trays, one for each pair of slots.
It’s a little tricky, and you frequently forget to empty them until it’s too late.
A single large crumb tray or a front-access tray is a fantastic alternative if you want to keep your toaster clean.

The best toasters to buy

SaleBestseller No. 1
Breville Bold Black 2-Slice Toaster with High-Lift and Wide Slots | Black and Silver Chrome [VTR001]
  • Glossy, ridged textured finish with high shine chrome accents and illuminated controls for ease of use
  • Variable width bread slots allow for both thick and thin slices
  • Variable browning control lets you pick your preferred shade of golden brown
  • Lift and Look function lets you check your toast mid-cycle; High Lift feature means smaller items can be removed easily without burning fingers
  • Defrost, reheat and mid-cycle cancel functions, plus removable crumb tray, non-slip base and cord storage
SaleBestseller No. 2
Russell Hobbs 26071 4 Slice Toaster - Contemporary Honeycomb Design with Extra Wide Slots and High Lift Feature, Black
  • Textured Design - The Honeycomb 4 Slice Black Toaster has a Textured Design with Stainless Steel Accents, that makes a statement on any kitchen counter.
  • High Lift Feature - Letting you easily remove your toast safely and easily from the Extra Wide Slots, this feature takes care of your fingertips.
  • Frozen, Cancel and Reheat Functions - Toast a slice straight from frozen, reheat that piece you’ve forgotten about, or press cancel to save your toast from burning.
  • Removable Crumb Tray - Say goodbye to crumbs all over the countertop. This handy tray collects all of your crumbs, ready to be emptied straight into the bin with minimal fuss.
  • 2 Year Manufactures Guarantee - Plus 1 extra year when you register the product online.
SaleBestseller No. 3
Russell Hobbs 24090 Adventure Four Slice, Brushed Polished Stainless Steel Toaster
  • Sleek stainless steel body with black Accents fit for any stylish kitchen
  • Variable browning control to suit your preference
  • 4 extra wide slots with independent 2 Slice operation, perfect for a variety of toasting from bread to crumpets
  • Lift and look feature so you can check on the stage of toasting without having to cancel and restart the cycle
  • Toaster
Bestseller No. 4
Morphy Richards 222067 Brushed Equip 2 Slice Stainless Steel Toaster, 800 W, Brushed
  • Cancel, reheat and defrost functions - For ease and convenience
  • Variable width slots - Evenly toasted bread every time, thick or thin
  • Variable Browning Control - Perfect toast just the way you like it, every time
  • Removable Crumb Tray - Easy to keep your toaster clean and tidy
  • Cord Storage - Keep your kitchen worktop neat and tidy
SaleBestseller No. 5
Toaster 2 Slice, Morpilot Stainless Steel Retro Toaster with Timer, Wide Slot, Defrost/Reheat/Cancel Fuction, Removable Crumb Tray, LED Display
  • ✨【LED Countdown Time Display】The sandwich toaster is equipped with an LED display to indicating toast progress. In this way you can see the baking accessories and the remaining time for the selected color setting at a glance.
  • ✨【6 Modes and Defrost / Heating / Cancel Function】Our electric toaster has 6 browning options and defrost / heating / cancel function. You can choose between light golden and deep dark roasted slices from 1 (light) to 6 (dark), depending on individual preferences.
  • ✨【1.5 Inch Wide Slice】 This 2 slice toaster has a 1.5 inch large slot with adjustment guides, making it suitable for a variety of breads such as thin waffles or thick artisan bread, and always keeps the bread It's also equipped with an automatic pop-up feature when the food is ready.
  • ✨【Easy to clean】Bread crumbs are collected in a removable tray at the bottom of the toaster. Just pull it out and clean the crumbs immediately! Underneath the toaster is even an uncomplicated cable wrap that lets you handle unsightly power cords after use.
  • ✨【High Lift Lever】The lever allows you to lift smaller items like small slices of bread out of the toaster slots.
SaleBestseller No. 6
Breville Curve 4-Slice Toaster with High Lift and Wide Slots | White & Chrome [VTT911]
  • Add eye-catching finishing touches to your kitchen with the Breville Curve Collection, featuring a curved texture design with high gloss finish and chrome accents
  • Variable width bread slots allow for both thick and thin slices
  • Variable browning control lets you pick your preferred shade of golden brown
  • High lift feature means smaller items can be removed easily without burning fingers
  • Defrost, reheat and mid-cycle cancel functions, plus removable crumb tray, non-slip base and cord storage
Bestseller No. 7
Breville VTT942 New York Collection 4 Slice Toaster with High-Lift and Wide Slots, White and Gold
  • Stunning high gloss design with textured and polished gold accents
  • White statement illumination around the base and control buttons
  • Lift & Look to check toast progress; High lift for removing smaller slices
  • Defrost, reheat & cancel; Variable width; Variable browning
  • Matching jug kettle
SaleBestseller No. 8
Morphy Richards 220026 Dune 2 Slice Toaster Defrost and Re-Heat Settings, Plastic, Black
  • Defrost setting - no need to defrost your bread first for ease and convenience
  • Re-heat setting - on those occasions where we forget, your toaster will quickly re-heat your toast for you
  • Variable browning control - perfect toast, just the way you like it
  • Removable crumb tray - easy to keep your toaster clean
  • Cord storage - excess cord can be tidied away to keep your kitchen worktops neat and clutter free
Bestseller No. 9
Smeg TSF01BLUK Retro 2 Slice Toaster, 6 Browning Levels, Extra-Wide Bread Slots, Defrost and Reheat Functions, Removable Crumb Tray, 950 W, Black
  • A elegantly deep drawn sheet steel two slice toaster featuring a retro design and extra wide slots for nice thick slices of bread and bagels; available in eight eye-catching colours
  • The flashy illuminated dials offer up to six varying browning levels to get the toast at the ideal texture for the most delicious results; also includes a bagel function
  • Includes handy defrost and reheat functions so you can easily toast your bread or bagels straight from frozen
  • Removable touch-release stainless steel crumb tray makes quick and easy work of disposing all of those excess crumbs
  • Built-in cord storage keeps your kitchen countertops nice and tidy, while the anti-slip feet keeps everything stable and in place
SaleBestseller No. 10
Russell Hobbs 18790 Futura 4-Slice Toaster, 1500 W, Stainless Steel Silver, Four Slice
  • 4 slice, wide slot toaster with independent 2 slice operation.
  • Frozen, cancel and reheat functions.
  • 6 stage variable browning control.
  • Removable crumb trays. Note : Please ensure that the crumb tray is cleaned regularly (Do not turn the toaster upside down to shave out bits).
  • 2 year guarantee.

Honest Bob is committed to providing genuine guides from a panel of experts. As an Amazon affiliate Honest Bob earns commission from any qualifying purchases.Thank you for your support!

Must Read